Gotta Luv It Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop

Tucked along Kingston Avenue in the small Sullivan County village of Wurtsboro, Gotta Luv It Pizzeria & Sandwich Shop feels exactly like the kind of neighborhood pizza spot locals rely on for a quick slice, a hearty sandwich, or a casual dinner after a long day. The location at 187 Kingston Ave places it right in the heart of town, making it an easy stop for both residents and travelers passing through the Catskills. From the outside it has that familiar, no-nonsense pizzeria look, but stepping inside reveals a welcoming, relaxed atmosphere where the focus is clearly on good food and friendly service rather than flashy décor.

The menu leans into classic pizzeria comfort foods while still offering enough variety to keep regulars interested. Pizza is naturally the centerpiece, and the slices tend to strike that satisfying balance of crisp crust, flavorful tomato sauce, and generous cheese. A simple cheese slice already hits the spot, but the specialty options-often loaded with toppings like pepperoni, sausage, peppers, or mushrooms-show the kitchen’s willingness to go a little bigger for customers who want something more filling. The crust has that slightly chewy texture that many East Coast pizza lovers expect, and the portions are large enough that one slice can feel like a meal.

Beyond pizza, the sandwich selection deserves attention as well. The shop lives up to the sandwich part of its name with a range of hot and cold subs, classic deli-style combinations, and hearty grinders. The chicken parm sandwich is a standout, stacked with breaded chicken, melted mozzarella, and marinara on toasted bread. It’s messy in the best possible way and pairs well with a side of fries or a quick soda from the counter. For lighter appetites, the menu also usually includes salads and simple sides that round out the experience.

The service here is casual but attentive, the kind you expect from a small-town pizzeria where staff often recognize repeat customers. Orders tend to come out quickly, which makes it a convenient lunch stop for locals working nearby. During busier hours the dining area can get lively, especially with families grabbing takeout or kids stopping in for a slice after school. Reviews from regular patrons often mention the consistent portions and fair prices, which is exactly what many people look for in a dependable pizza shop.

What makes the place memorable is its sense of local character. Wurtsboro isn’t a huge town, and restaurants here often double as community gathering spots. This pizzeria fits that role comfortably, offering familiar food, a relaxed setting, and a menu that delivers straightforward comfort without trying to overcomplicate things. Visitors exploring the nearby Catskill region or driving along Route 209 frequently find it to be a convenient place to refuel, while locals appreciate having a reliable spot for pizza night, quick sandwiches, and easy takeout.